June 16, 2022
Penn State Fayette is defining the vision of excellence.
| Year | Sport | Award |
| 2021 | Men's Cross Country | PSUAC Invitational Championship |
| 2021 | Women's Cross Country | USCAA National Invitational Runner-up |
| 2021 | Women's Cross Country | PSUAC Invitational Championship |
| 2019 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2019 | Volleyball | USCAA National Championship |
| 2019 | Track and Field | USCAA National Invitational Championship |
| 2018 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2017 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship Runner-up |
| 2017 | Men's Cross Country | PSUAC Championship |
| 2016 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2016 | Men's Cross Country | PSUAC Championship |
| 2015 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship Runner-up |
| 2015 | Men's Cross Country | PSUAC Championship |
| 2014 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2013 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2012 | Women's Basketball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2012 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2012 | Men's Basketball | USCAA National Championship Runner-Up |
| 2011 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2010 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2009 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2008 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2007 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2006 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2005 | Volleyball | PSUAC Championship |
| 2004 | Baseball | PSUAC Championship |